Posted by: gb05 | March 26, 2008

It’s Flat, but keeps spinning round

Nick Davies’ book ‘Flat Earth News’ is providing an interesting read. Not only as a student studying journalism, but also as a person who reads newspapers.

And considering the main story on ‘The Sun’ website, it’s hard to suggest otherwise that British news is more related to ‘churnalism’ than ‘journalism’.

 ’Man Pregnant’ is more Daily Sport than the Sun, but remember, this is a paper that once printed ‘Freddie Starr ate my Hamster’.

Indeed, that was not a true story, but more a marvellous piece of PR by Max Clifford, to help Freddie promote his tour (which went on to sell out across the country.)

Reading more into the ‘Man Pregnant’ story, my mind was switching to the idea of ‘churnalism’.

Whilst reading Davies’ book, I didn’t actually want to believe him. The work of the great journalists in the world today, is that churnalism?

Having finished reading the website, I flick onto my local rag the ‘Reading Evening Post’ website, and everything I feared becomes true.

Week after week, the Post produces a rag with no real news. Viewing the comments on their news stories, it seems like the residents of Reading agree.

Milicent Davis is a prolific commenter, mainly along the lines of ‘have you got any real news today?’, ‘Shock horror: evening post in real news shocker’. And to be fair, he’s got a point.

The Scrote, as is refered to by certain sections of the borough, has become nothing more than the councils mouth piece.

Their biggest piece of churnalism, is allowing the Green Party to run a piece about how one of their men is living, while only creating one bin full of waste.

But they haven’t only been able to get that as a main feature, the same man who is hoping to create one bin of waste, has also lived in a tent in a car park for a week, to show we can all live at zero carbon-footprint.

Nothing made me want to run the bath every day, fill the kettle up to full for just one cup than having to read and see the beardy-weirdy, Worzel on the front page of a paper.

I had wondered why on earth the Post went for this story. And unfortunately, Davies provided the answer. It’s ‘churnalism’ at its very best, they provide the story, and the Post put it out for all to see.

And that would be it. On local newsroom, with staff struggling to output copy, ‘churnalism’ runs wild.

Instead, today, ‘churnalism’ is advent on the front page of national news. It was betraying to everything that is journalism. Everything that I have studied. Everything that I believed.

I’ll defend journalism to the high-hill with anyone, but today is a dark-dark day. Today, there is no news worthy of being on the front page.

It might as well have been blank.


Responses

  1. This is a good one. Up towards the standard of the City University blogs. They are talking about Nick Davies as well. You should cross-link to those blogs, then we can get a bit of student to student action going across the boundaries of the colleges.

    In the meantime I have been up late setting up WINOL – Winchester News Online. This is sort of like Alfie, but will be part of the course in year three. Also you will have the second years and the new first years at your disposal to work as reporters, writer, go-fers, etc. This you might think is a mixed blessing – but at least you’ll be able to boss ‘em about a bit.

    In the meantime for the ‘dummy’ edition of WINOL I want to use this piece as content to fill out the template.

    WINOL is based on the work I did at Westminster where the staff team there won the BJTC ‘innovation in journalism education’ for two years running. So all of this is going to be a lot of fun.

  2. I really like this as a piece of writing and think that you raise some very good points.

    The difficulty i think comes with drawing the line between ‘Churnalism’ and Journalism. Who decides which is which, at the end of the day surely the audience, the recipient, the buyer.

    Even though ‘Freddie Starr Ate My Hamster’ is clearly not serious news, if that was the lead and there was an upsurge in circulation then surely that is news to certain people.

    I see your point and some ‘news’ really isn’t news, hence the fact that 24 hour tv news, bangs on about ‘receiving breaking news’ when 9 times out of 10 it’s totally irrelevant and doesn’t even get a mention on the main bulletins later on.

    I enjoyed this piece and look forward to reading more soon.

  3. This is one of the better ones. Good subjects. Tight, grammatical stuff.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories